Parenting has never been easy, and this past year has ushered in all kinds of new challenges for those raising children. New guidelines cover just about every aspect of society, from going to a restaurant to taking care of your kids. It’s worth comparing time-tested parenting techniques with today’s modern parenting.
What was once deemed not acceptable is now the preferred method of modern parenting. And the kind of things we readers did as kids would be like some kind of unimaginable science fiction if such options were presented to children today.
Screen time used to be limited but now it’s all-consuming.
Up until this past year, every pediatrician and child-rearing book recommended limiting screen time to no more than two hours a day for young children. Pediatricians advised using careful observation and planning around screen time for older children. We widely understood it’s easy for screen time to push more worthwhile activities such as playing outside, socializing, interacting with family members, and reading out of the schedule. There has been extensive research on this.
This article is not about passing judgment on parents using screens to distract children. I turned on movies plenty of times when my children were small if I needed to get something done. However, I always understood it was less than ideal, and so did every other parent I knew. Screen usage correlates with eye problems, sleep problems, and posture problems. Most parents knew this instinctively and tried to get kids otherwise engaged whenever possible.
Suddenly, it is not only okay but preferable to keep children in front of screens for ten or twelve hours a day. Kids now do both their school and their socializing online. I guess it’s better to deal with the known evils of screen usage, lack of exercise, and minimal social interaction, than to risk exposure to an illness for which children under 19 have a survival rate of 99.997%?
All of a sudden, homeschooling is favored
I wouldn’t say attitudes have changed society-wide. Still, I have noticed an extreme shift in the attitude toward homeschooling.
When I was growing up, it seemed homeschooling led to socially dysfunctional children. I knew homeschooled kids, but I thought they were weird, and so did my parents. Time makes fools of us all. My attitude toward homeschooling changed when my child struggled in our school district.
Even after homeschooling for nearly a decade, I still had people ask how my children could socialize and function in the “real world.” I just assumed I would spend the rest of my time as a homeschooling parent explaining myself to people.
Don’t get me wrong. I’ve learned to love homeschooling. It was my personal choice, which every parent deserves. I had time to research before pulling my child from public school. And, I had a spouse who was (somewhat) willing to pay me to homeschool. Homeschooling has its advantages, but a functional public school system has its benefits too. Every parent deserves honest information:
- The concerns about lack of socialization are real. Experienced homeschoolers know they need to plan for that. Children need to form relationships outside of their families.
- As children get older, they need to take responsibility for their scheduling. As a parent, it’s often too easy to keep managing things for them. I know that’s been one of my big struggles, and that was why I wanted my children to attend public high school.
Pumping children full of pharmaceuticals is now the norm
Another aspect of modern parenting (which has always struck me as strange though it’s about to hit a new level of crazy) is the attitude toward pharmaceuticals. I’ve seen parents shame other parents over letting their children consume high fructose corn syrup or artificial food dyes. But pumping children full of drugs? That’s totally normal.
Note: this isn’t about judging people who need to medicate their children for one reason or another.
My point is the extreme caution we’re expected to exercise when it comes to food, but the total abandonment of any questioning when it comes to pharmaceuticals. No, I don’t think the food scientists always have our health at the forefront of their minds. But I don’t believe pharmaceutical companies do either.
If a bowl of cereal makes me sick, I can sue the pants off the company. They’re pretty motivated to make sure their products are, if not healthy, at least not immediately poisonous. However, pharmaceutical companies are under no such constraints. As America’s Frontline Doctors point out in their White Paper on Experimental Vaccines: since 1986, pharmaceutical companies have been shielded from any liability regarding adverse effects of their vaccines.
That means, if you have such a strong reaction to a vaccine you need to be hospitalized, they don’t have to pay you a cent. You cannot sue pharmaceutical companies for an adverse reaction to a vaccine. It also means pharmaceutical companies are highly incentivized to treat everything with vaccines. My kids are vaccinated, though I won’t get them the Covid shot any time soon. I’m simply trying to point out the logical fallacies parents are increasingly expected to swallow.
NOTE: once again, I’m not trying to pick a fight about vaccination, though if you are interested, I strongly recommend the White Paper referenced above.
What happened to,” It takes a village to raise a child”?
Just as Americans were once used to independently operating family physicians, we were once used to raising our children in smaller communities. If parents couldn’t provide constant care, friends, neighbors, and extended family usually did. My great-grandmother died in childbirth; her siblings all stepped in to raise my grandmother. Likewise, when my grandfather died during my dad’s childhood, my grandmother’s brother stepped in to help out.
It’s a lot harder to do that these days. Extended families don’t live close to each other. Neighborhoods are less safe; you can’t just let kids wander around and do whatever. Daycares and public schools have filled that gap.
However, like the hospital groups that manage doctors, the various childcare institutions have their own agendas.
Schools around the country still haven’t fully reopened
I have always thought that most teachers and childcare providers genuinely like children. But watching them use school reopenings as bargaining chips for various benefits has made me question that. Los Angeles teachers were instructed not to post vacation pictures online. This was an attempt to maintain that it was too dangerous for teachers to return to work.
This sort of thing isn’t only in LA, though. In Aurora, Colorado, I have friends that teach. They were provided with free childcare, paid for by taxpayers who mostly lost their childcare so that they could teach remotely without interruption.
More than a year into the pandemic, most Colorado schools are still not open full time. And they’ve changed a lot throughout the year. My son’s high school started remotely, went back one day a week, then back to completely remote, then one day a week, then two days a week. And other school districts have been far worse about changing things around.
Be aware of how much news, particularly involving children, is being suppressed
The Wall Street Journal ran an article just this week about YouTube censoring a roundtable discussion hosted by Florida’s governor Ron DeSantis. He discussed Covid policies with physicians from Harvard, Oxford, and Stanford. They discussed a variety of topics, including the damaging effects of requiring children to wear masks. Despite the fact all the panelists were renowned experts in their respective fields, YouTube banned the video as “misinformation.”
I wouldn’t have known that.
The Wall Street Journal costs about $40/month. My dad was kind enough to get me a gift subscription a while back. My point is, there is a lot of news being buried right now. Unless you spend a lot of time and money online, it’s tough to find.
How about prepping as a modern aspect of parenting?
My kids are old enough to be actively involved in gardening, animal care, and food preservation. It’s given us structure in the day when our other planned activities have fallen by the wayside. My kids have other living creatures with which to bond. It’s not the same as hanging out with friends at school, but it’s better than nothing. They aren’t in front of a screen.
I present our food production as a fun hobby that also happens to be healthy and profitable. I have no official childcare credentials other than the fact that my children and I have been mostly stuck with each other for a long time, and we still get along. My children are somewhat depressed compared to 18 months ago. But they are not suicidal, abusing substances, or suffering from the conditions that seem to be tormenting so many of their peers. That must count for something.
Daisy wrote this excellent article describing one side-effect of the pandemic and subsequent restrictions: mental health issues. She offers suggestions on how to help those who are struggling with mental health issues.
Prepping with children will look different for everyone
Jose has written about fixing things with his son. My friends that are firearms instructors take their kids to the range. A friend that raises sheep has taught her children to shear. Friends in the suburbs work on their little urban homesteads together. It doesn’t have to involve a lot of money, but it gives all of us a slight sense of control that we so desperately need in this world of constantly changing social norms.
Children need their parents to provide structure, guidance, and routine until they are old enough to self-regulate. Parents need to be strong to give that structure within a society that has other priorities. However, with the increased reliance on childcare professionals, most parents I know don’t have confidence in their parenting abilities, common with older generations.
We Gen-Xer parents need to come into our power. We’ve been written off as the laid back, “whatever” generation of Wayne and Garth. That was fine when things were running smoothly.
What are your thoughts on today’s modern parenting?
We are the ones responsible for our children, whom we know better than anyone else. We need to take a page out of the self-satisfied Boomer book and parent in whatever way best suits our children, without listening to every “expert” that comes along. Has parenting become more difficult for you over the past year? If so, how? Have you found new ways to parent that suit you and your children better? Let’s talk about it in the comments below.
About Joanna Miller
Joanna has been homeschooling three children since 2012. In 2014, she moved to the High Plains of Colorado. She and her children began a little homestead, gardening and raising chickens for eggs and meat. One animal led to another, and these days they have livestock guardian dogs, chickens, geese, ducks, alpacas, goats, pigs, and one very spoiled cat.
“Homeschooling has its advantages, but a functional public school system has its benefits too”
public school is better by far, homeschooling is definitely a second choice. but of course when public schools are replaced by dysfunction and communist propaganda then homeschooling is the alternative.
“Suddenly, it is not only okay but preferable to keep children in front of screens for ten or twelve hours a day”
identify who it is that is pushing that, and you’ve identified the actual problem.
Just curious….how many kiddos do you have that informs your opinion that public school is “better by far”?
Public schools certainly vary based on location. The schools in my rural area have very conservative-minded teachers and administrators. That might be different in larger cities. We’ve never had an issue with “indoctrination” in public schools or the university my oldest now attends. With my three boys, we’ve done homeschooling, charter schools, and public schools. Each child has their individual needs and we’ve educated each child differently because of that. Implying that all public schools have an indoctrination agenda isn’t really fair.
We homestead and teach our children on a daily basis — about a variety of topics, from animal husbandry, to basic construction, to immigration policy. They work hard and have a stronger ethic than most adults. My husband and I also raise our children to be free and critical thinkers, and how to interact with people who believe differently. Public schools provide an opportunity to practice that interaction. I think that’s a really important life skill.
My son is 10 and has ADHD. Public school has never been ideal for either of us (I also have ADHD and the public school system failed me), but are on our 3rd round of online schooling here in Ontario and I’ve had a lot of talk with his teacher about him not participating online. We’ve decided that she will send me documents of what she is teaching online, and I’m sending her a list of things that I may try as alternatives if I can’t follow along since I’m trying to make it fun at home, otherwise, it’s a huge battle and no one wins. I’ve discovered Minecraft: Education Edition and it has lesson plans that go along with the core curriculum which has been a HUGE hit this time around. We’ve only been working on one subject this way so far but I’m planning on using it for others as well. As long as he’s learning, the teacher is happy so she’s given me lots of other ideas too.
I’m also setting up a daily schedule with one-hour blocks of time (but no actual times, if we wake at 10 am, the day starts then), giving him free time for an hour right away, and then 1-hour school and/or chores, 1-hour break, and repeat until we’ve gotten through what we need to for that day. Followed by getting outdoors for hiking or skatepark after dinner or during the day if it is nice out. I’m also planning on getting him more involved with dinner planning and preparation, baking, and other routine maintenance stuff around the house. If he’s going to be here, he may as well learn about the things I have to do when he’s normally at school. Next week, I also have to start another class so getting him into a fun learning program is huge for me to also get my own stuff done (class and thesis writing).
I have had a lot of problems with my own concentration in regards to my own school work, so I can’t imagine having to sit through online schooling for 6 hours a day! Not going to happen here. Even if we both have to repeat a year, I’d rather try making it fun so we can both get through this. There are no rules when it comes to this stuff, so do what works and enjoy the time with family first!
We should not be forced to pay via property taxes to public schools, that push communism and critical race theory, if our children do not attend or choose not to participate in public schooling (aka government indoctrination centers).
As Thomas Jefferson said…
“To compel a man to furnish funds for the propagation of ideas he disbelieves and abhors is sinful and tyrannical.”
“What happened to,” It takes a village to raise a child”?”
Well it’s simple. Society changed. They will sue you for saying anything about their kids. They will troll you on social media because you tried to watch out for them playing in traffic. They encourage bad behavior and dressing like thugs because they do it as well. Kids dressing gansta and adults dressing like hell angels just because they own a motorcycle.
There are a few places left where things are as they were but folks need to accept that it has changed.
It never took a village to raise a child. It takes parents, grandparents, and other relatives. It takes friends and their families. The “village” never has cared about your child except for damages to life and property or how much they irritate them. That phrase was from Leftist Hillary Clinton; who of course, sent her daughter to the best private schools. It is based in Communist Theory, where parents are simply breeders to provide slaves to the state.
Societies always change. Values and belief systems always shift. I appreciate Joanna’s article because it provides alternative actions one can take to flex to that change. This is important because there are onpy two ways to respond; adjust or do nothing. The people who do nothing are usually those who complain the loudest and most frequently yet expect others to compensate for their lack of action towards self-interest (read self preservation).
Homeschooling has been viewed negatively for many years. I consider that to be a point of ignorance. I have many friends, with actual chlidren, who are service spouses who homeschool simply to keep educational continuity through multiple station changes. I have seen first hand that the homeschooling communities are strong, resourceful and offer diverse specialties, from chemistry to ballet. That is the village-parents who share and trade skills, and children who are intelligent and resilient.
Our kids, at ALL LEVELS, are being taught a deplorable system of segregation and violence under the guise of progressivism. There is nothing progressive about it. While “new” to the USA, these recidivist values are meant to break down the existing society to build a new one in a BLM image. Anyone who has lived under a Communist system and retained their mental freedom hates what they are witnessing. One need look no further than Canada to find priests who fight back.
Lockdowns and other non-pharmacutical interventions are hand in glove with critical race theory, marxist ideologies, and accepted violence. Joanna is putting tools in our toolkits to continue to adjust and adapt, and for that she should be thanked.
I raised my 4 plus over a dozen kids that lived with us at time a over the 22 years I operated a church school here. I cooked, sewed and taught classes, raised funds to stay open and recruited volunteers.
I started out with home schooling child 3 after his gradeschool flunked most of the 3rd grade so they couId start special ed classes. Surprise… most of that class either went to church schools or home schooled. After not repeating 3rd but doing 4th grade I opened a school here. Never more than 49 students it was aiming to prepare mostly Native American students for college. I taught 7th to 12th grades. I ended up teaching math up to pre calculus. Many students earned who’s who in American High School students listing and some earned college tuition help.
I agree its hard making the right choice for each family and for each child. My 2nd son started running with a trouble crowd at public High School. I pulledhim out at Christmas Break his junior year. Hee was mad but buckled down and did the rest of his junior year and all of his senior year in 1/2 school year. Graduated not just early but with extra credits. Whew… that worked.
Oldest son with government certified 180+ IQ graduated from Public School and did well.
Daughter taught herself to read and do math so at age 4 she a as reading at 2nd grade level and doing math at 3rd grade level. Easily bored. Too bright for most classes. She finished High School at 14 with over double the required credits. Public School wasn’t a good choice for her. At 12 she was teaching the preschoolers to read. She had a real talent for that. Home schooling wouldn’t have let her let her find that passion for working with little kids. Today she has 20 years of experience working in day care centers. She’s a licensed administrator and has 8 years of corporate experience and teaches day care teachers and helps younger teachers with classroom problems. She also does the company data entry, payroll, and more.
The school with small classes, for her was a perfect answer. Each child is different and every parent must make the best choices they can. It’s been a crazy, hard year for families.
Homeschooling is THE choice for parents right now if at least one parent is able to stay home. Spent 2 years homeschooling my 2 boys. #1 graduated from small town public High School with a 3.6 GPA & 3.2 GPA from small town college. Went straight into police academy and will graduate next month. #2 son graduated 1st in class with a 4.0 GPA and is now a sophomore in college. Totally online, he is really struggling to stay motivated, has no social interaction and teachers are barely available to any questions, all on zoom of course.