Is the US Funding an Experiment in Digital Control in Ukraine?

(Psst: The FTC wants me to remind you that this website contains affiliate links. That means if you make a purchase from a link you click on, I might receive a small commission. This does not increase the price you'll pay for that item nor does it decrease the awesomeness of the item. ~ Daisy)

Fighting between Russia and Ukraine has been going on for a little over a year now, ending the lives of hundreds of thousands of young men and displacing millions.  Ukraine’s Defense Minister, Oleksii Reznikov, invited Western arms manufacturers to test their newest weapons against Russians in 2022. And indeed, all kinds of weaponry have been flowing into Ukraine.  It is truly a testing ground.

So, this begs the question, is anything else getting tested there?  The Ukrainian government seems pretty willing to use its own citizens as guinea pigs, and the American government seems pretty willing to foot the bill.  Are American tax dollars going to any other interesting projects?

Here’s what the US is funding in Ukraine.

Yes, actually.  Volodymyr Zelensky became president of Ukraine in May 2019, and almost immediately he introduced his idea of a “country in a smartphone.”

In early September 2019, Ukraine launched its Ministry of Digital Transformation, headed by a World Economic Forum participant, Mykhailo Fedorov  According to Federov, the goal of this new government department was to streamline government services, making it easier to apply for driver’s licenses, passports, and so on.  Ukraine has long held the reputation as Europe’s most corrupt country, and young politicians like Federov want to take advantage of new technology to make changes.

So, in early February 2020, the Ukrainian government launched its Diia app for smartphones.  Developed by volunteers from EPAM Systems, Diaa has been touted as a way to streamline government services.  By 2021 it had allowed Ukraine to become the first European nation to accord digital passports and one of the first to issue digital drivers’ licenses.  Federov reported in 2021 that about one-fourth of the Ukrainian population was using it, and it was gaining in popularity.  As of January 2023, about half the adult Ukrainian population was using it.

There is a positive side to streamlining government services.  Diia has allowed Ukrainians to easily start new businesses, making all the required government paperwork easily available.  I can see this being helpful for young entrepreneurs.

However, negative consequences became readily apparent, too.

Within a year of its launch, millions of Ukrainians found that their personal data, such as driver’s licenses, social media information, and banking information, were being traded online.  There’s always been the risk of losing your wallet and your driver’s license, but with everything online, the risks of fraud and identity theft increase astronomically.

Early on in his presidency, Zelensky talked about streamlining the voting process via the app.  Aside from the fact that experts have never agreed about the safety of online voting, by July 2022, Zelensky had banned political opposition parties and shut down media companies with alternative views. Having one central app that controls everyone’s important documents makes it far easier for any ruling party to maintain its power.

Controlling elections is only the beginning.  Diia launched in February 2020, and by March 2020, Diia was helping the Ukrainian government enforce its lockdown policies, as discussed in the recent report by Redacted.

The Redacted report shows portions of various WEF summits and at 2:06 has a clip of a WEF paper saying, “This digital identity determines what products, services, and information we can access—or conversely, what is closed off to us.”  Diia (and other digital identity products) have been marketed as a convenience, but don’t be fooled.  Developers of this technology have seen their potential as a control mechanism from the beginning.

The Redacted report also shows clips of Federov speaking at the 2021 WEF summit, and at 5:40 he openly admits that the pandemic allowed the Ukrainian government to speed up Ukraine’s digital transformation.  “The pandemic has accelerated our progress,” says Federov.  “People are really now demanding digital online services.  People have no choice but to trust technology.”

The Redacted report traces Diia’s transformation from a convenient service to a military tool.  At 6:39, they discuss an interview in Wired with Anton Melnyk, an adviser in Ukraine’s Ministry for Digital Transformation.  In March 2022, Dr. Melnyk stated, “We have restructured the Ministry of Digital Transformation into a clear military organization.”

Wartime features in an app

Shortly after the Russian invasion, Diia added all kinds of new wartime features.  Ukrainians can report Russian troop movements through Diia’s chatbot, eVorog (eEnemy).  Ukrainians can receive government payments even if they’re displaced.  But Diia doesn’t stop there.

Diia encourages citizens to snitch on their neighbors.  The wartime features allow any citizen to anonymously accuse any other citizen of being a Russian collaborator.  Stalin’s rule in the Soviet Union demonstrated how wrong this can go.  Ukrainians hate Stalin, and rightfully so.  But using cutting-edge technology to encourage the exact same kind of community-destroying snitching is a page right out of his playbook.  Between the snitching and its one official, government-approved news station, Diia is rapidly becoming Stalin in a smartphone.

Here’s why Americans should care.

In case you’re wondering why we should care about the ins and outs of Ukrainian bureaucracy, there are two big reasons worth paying attention to this.  The first is that Americans have been paying for much of the technical development.  The second is that the “government in a smartphone” concept is rapidly spreading around the world.

USAID has been supporting Ukraine’s digital transformation since 2016.  The volunteers that developed Diia were Ukrainians working with EPAM Systems, a software engineering company based in Pennsylvania.  And EPAM Systems may be a private company, but USAID isn’t. It’s taxpayer-funded.

After the Russian invasion, USAID donated another $8.5 million to Ukraine to help develop Diia’s wartime features.  USAID director Samantha Power spoke at the World Economic Forum in 2023, touting Diia’s success.  She and Federov both talked about the huge successes and discussed sharing Diia’s model with other countries.  Incidentally, Samantha Power is married to Cass Sunstein, the author of Nudge and a number of other books that some might consider pro-social-manipulation.

Power has stated that USAID intends to look for leaders in developing nations that have been running on anti-corruption platforms and sharing Diia-like technology with them to help modernize their countries.  She specifically cited Zambia, the Dominican Republic, and Ecuador. In January, Estonia announced that they would begin trial runs of their mRiik app, modeled after Ukraine’s Diia.

And, of course, all of this sounds very loving and charitable. However, it’s impossible to ignore the financial incentives.

The digital shift in America

The U.S. got a giant shove online when lockdowns were enforced in 2020 and 2021.  The U.S.’s “digital transformation,” even though it was only partial, still made already-wealthy tech companies even wealthier. Even though billionaire wealth can fluctuate pretty dramatically, by the end of 2022, American billionaires were still 50% richer than pre-pandemic.

Lovers of free-market economics will point out that increased technological ability is a rising wave that lifts everyone.  That can be true, but ask yourself, are most people you know 50% richer than before the pandemic?  Probably not.  Our lives have been getting pushed online over the past few years.  Some people profited, but the quality of life of the average citizen decreased.

Combine the shift to a digital world with the reconstruction after wartime destruction, and you see huge opportunities for profit.  It’s estimated that rebuilding Ukraine, so far, will cost over $1 trillion.  Zelensky and BlackRock CEO Larry Fink have already come to an agreement about managing the rebuilding of Ukraine.  USAID may be charitable, but BlackRock isn’t.  Ukraine is in the process of being destroyed and being rebuilt.  This is going to be hugely profitable for certain people, and Big Tech seems to be intent on getting their slice of the pie.

This kind of thing isn’t new.  Brigadier General Smedley Butler, combat veteran and Medal of Honor recipient, wrote War Is a Racket back in the 1930s.  The book is full of examples of industries generating huge wartime profits in conflicts a hundred years ago.  War profiteering isn’t new. It isn’t a conspiracy. It’s human nature.

There’s no reason not to think that the same powerful Big Tech figures will not continue to push the expansion of their businesses by pushing life around the world online, with or without violent conflict.

Will we all be pushed into government-by-smartphone?

Maybe some emerging markets will be helped by Diia-like apps.  But what about countries that already had reasonably safe and secure government services?  Will functional governments be pushed onto a smartphone?

It’s likely, though not imminent.  The Improving Digital Identity Act of 2021 is in Congress right now. There are a few versions of it under review. The Senate version actually states that the government cannot require digital identity for any kind of transaction.

Americans are still, on average, relatively concerned about privacy and the concentration of power.  The many concerns surrounding Centralized Bank Digital Currencies apply to digital identification, as well.  The OP ran an article last month discussing the total loss of anonymity that will occur when CBDCs become implemented.

And there are other, less discussed applications.  Look at geofencing.  A federal district judge just issued a first-ever “geofencing” warrant for anyone in the vicinity of the Capitol on January 6.  This gave police the authority to search the cell phone data of every American whose coordinates happened to be in the area, regardless of whether or not they had anything to do with the shenanigans at the Capitol.

Imagine if they could pull your driver’s license or freeze your bank account, too.  Right now, that’s not possible. With all of your important documents linked to something like Diia, it could be.

Here’s how it could unfold.

I don’t think we will all be forced onto something like Diia in the space of a year, but I think we’re at the beginning of a certain chain of events.  Digital IDs begin to be offered as a convenience, they become popular, they begin to be preferred by businesses and governments, and we eventually lose the option of physical IDs.  And, of course, some kind of crisis (climate change, another pandemic, a hot war) could speed this up more quickly, as happened in Ukraine.

The tools to implement a CBDC linked to a digital identity are already out there.  Look at China’s social credit system.  It’s technically possible for us, too. It sounds crazy, but conspiracy theorists have been proven correct so consistently lately I don’t think skepticism regarding these new, profitable technologies is unreasonable.

How to retain our privacy

We need to remember that life’s about more than convenience.  It’s about the freedom to try new things, some of which will fail spectacularly and some of which will lead to resounding successes.  That combination of failure and success is what leads to the deeper insights that make most of us into interesting people.  If we continue to trade privacy for convenience, we may find we don’t have much freedom left, either.

If we want to retain some measure of privacy and control over our own lives, if we want to avoid the techno-prison currently being constructed for us, if Americans don’t want our own “Stalin in a smartphone,” we need to avoid feeding the digital beast.  Yes, it’s hard, and no, it’s not going to be realistic for 99.9% of us to live completely offline.  But we can keep our friendships and purchases offline as much as possible.  We can drag our feet when it comes to getting the newest smart gadgets.  Perhaps most importantly, those of us with teenagers and young adults can spend time explaining our privacy concerns to the younger generation, so they try to live life offline, as well.

The digital prison is being constructed, but it’s by no means done yet.  Grand plans like “government in a smartphone” always fall apart at some point.  The problems with Diia are obvious to anyone paying attention.  If enough of us can postpone moving everything online, hopefully, this impetus will collapse on its own.

What do you think about all of this?

Do you think the US is funding Diia in Ukraine as a testing ground for rolling out the technology? Were you aware of the crackdown on dissent by Zelensky? How do you maintain your online privacy? What will you do if everything moves to a digital app?

Let’s talk about it in the comments.

About Marie Hawthorne

A lover of novels and cultivator of superb apple pie recipes, Marie spends her free time writing about the world around her.

Picture of Marie Hawthorne

Marie Hawthorne

A lover of novels and cultivator of superb apple pie recipes, Marie spends her free time writing about the world around her.

Leave a Reply

  • I never owned a smartphone. My ISP provider has tried consistently to sell me a e-phone for the last twenty years and yet I refuse still. My rationale is that I do not have more to say today that I had in the seventies. I remember when my parents bought a “touchtone” phone and was installed were the older model stood just beside the back entrance of the farmhouse. My mom used to say “call your friend before going playing”. And the conversation usually lasted 25 seconds just the time for me to say “hey I am coming to your place be there in five minutes”. That is what I had to say in the seventies and since I have not changed regarding the use of phones even “touchtone” phones… And my Grand-Father refused the “touchtone” phone until the 1990’s decade holding dearly to the old rotary phone. My Grand-Father had to give up his beloved rotary phone because the thing was not supported anymore by Bell Canada.

  • Except for forums and sites like this one, I don’t do much online. I’ve bought a few things online over the last 12 or 13 years, using a load as you go debit card. I’ve used the same card for years, until about 2 years ago. In that time I’ve been hacked four times. Luckily, the card provider is pretty good about notifying me if a transaction looks suspicious, so I’ve not lost a large amount of money (only about $25 – $30 so far). Now I’m on my 4th reissued card number. I still question how they’re hacking me? I don’t store passwords or card data on my phone. Nothing that would make it easy to hack. The point is, all those years without a problem until Biden took office. What else did that Demented Liar do during the lockdown? Did he make Internet transactions easier to access by hackers with his Secret Squirrel schit?

  • I’m the target of jokes in my family with my ‘paranoia’ of tech. I call it skepticism. 😉 I’m not a complete dork but due to my sensitivities of the EMFs in such things, I try & stay away as much as possible so I look much differently at WIFI, cells towers, antennas, ‘smart’ apps. Two of the 3 of my military kids work in sat com & data flow areas & insist that cells are ‘safe & effective’. Lol, I know different & I tell them the military would hardly tell them they are hurting their health.

    The installation of cell towers & repeaters every 50 ft in airports got my attention one day. These were sneakily installed on our churches & schools during the lockdowns when no one was there & watching. I mean really, do we NEED to have them literally every 200 ft on city streets for downloading a movie?? Lies, all lies.

    Everyone shouted for joy for 5G for better download speed. I knew this was a beginning to facial recognition & tracking. Being a Christian & understanding End of Times, the book of Revelation & the book of Daniel, the hairs on the back of my neck sprung up when the CBDC idea was introduced.

    Interpreting Scripture is to understand receiving that the Mark of the Beast will be needed to buy & sell (unless underground/hidden or something like that). What that ‘mark’ is just yet, I have no idea. But we will know when we do or don’t take it. It will be a ‘choice’…take it or die. I will choose death, thank you. It sure seems like CBDC is making this easier to accomplish. But since we seem to be SO close to a global government & digital banking system & this administration is so utterly insidious & corrupt…we are so very close to what Scripture calls The End of Times.

    I know how it turns out, just didn’t think I’d see it in this lifetime. I do buy online way too much & hubby is slowing coming on board to doomsday like thinking. He’s realized that all my engaging on this site has helped us be a bit more prepared & educated. So that’s great! Thank you all.

    When this administration encouraged support for Ukraine & then Amazon was advertising support then billboards were going up to support them…I knew Ukraine was as corrupt as this administration.

    I might have bunny trailed a bit. 🙂

    • I agree with you 100% and choose death also. I’ve learned over the past 10 years or so to just keep my mouth shut, because 999 out of 1000 won’t believe it anyway. Most would rather believe a lie. It’s touching to know there are some of God’s children (my brothers and sisters) out there who believe as I do. Thank you for posting. I wish we were neighbors.

      • Awww thanks Joe. We are out there & hope others will join! 😉

        It’s a balance these days to keep hope & optimism.

  • “is anything else getting tested there”? Do you mean besides the latest in killing machines, digital currency control of the population and bioweapons? What else is there?

  • Fighting between Russia and Ukraine has been going on ever since the US gov helped force out the Russian friendly president of Ukraine.
    That’s when Ukraine started attacking those regions that sided with Russia,
    specifically Donetsk and Luhans’k area’s in 2014, under bomma then much later installing a bad comedian as the next president, the USA puppet who grew up lower middle class, now some how worth millions.. I wonder where all that money came from.
    Anyways, the Russian special military thing was in response to those attacks to protect their people, to shut down some of our 46 bio labs and keep US nuclear weapons off the Russian boarder.
    We wouldn’t tolerate another nations nuclear weapons on our boarder, why should they?

    It goes on and on.. you will never hear this on the lefty news.

    • Horse: now that you have regurgitated Russian propaganda…

      When the “Soviet Union collapsed” (they didn’t really, the KGB is still in control, Putin is KGB) they left crooked puppets in power in the “former Soviet satellites” like Lukashenko of Belarus who stay in power through crooked elections. The Ukrainian people rose up and drove their puppet out, along with the corrupt “businessmen” connected to Moscow, such as Burisma Oil that had bribed Joe and Hunter Biden on behalf of Moscow. Russia responded by invading Crimea and sending troops into eastern Ukraine to start a fake rebellion there. The Ukrainians remember the Holodomor which is why they are fighting so hard against the Russians today.

      There’s a lot more going on behind the scenes, much of it complex and confusing (perhaps deliberately confusing?) so we don’t know what is really happening. Why are the MSM and politicians so keen on helping Ukraine? Is there an ulterior motive?

  • Everything in Ukraine is a test for ultimate WEF ???? control.
    There’s a short video floating around of what Ukraine in a Centralized Utopia will ???? like. A version of 15’ min City on a country scale!
    Larry Fink of BlackRock a (WEF acolyte) will use the managed assets of Corporations & its shareholders under BlackRock management to push CBDC, ESG on a decimated population, as USA is continuing this proxy war down to the last Ukrainian! What a Disaster!

    Meantime in Europe theres already huge protests against the continued war, not seen on our corrupt MSM. Here in this country it’s crickets ???? cuz folks don’t think this affects them. Reason why Biden ???? ran to Ukraine to give Zelensky another .5 Billion ($100B+ so far) while Palestine OH was burning! Very Sad

  • This digital thing, it would only work if forced with no other options.
    The US dollar, good for all debts public and private.
    That would by necessity have to go, the general public wouldn’t let that go.

    Too many lefty positions, plans and agenda’s have been ruined, pushed out past implementation or outright ignored.
    Agenda 2021 now 2030.
    I see some issues are being forced on us now, much faster than in the past when they would take decades to push idea’s and ideals.

  • You wrote: “War profiteering isn’t new. It isn’t a conspiracy. It’s human nature.”
    FALLEN “human nature”

  • Digital identity can be a good thing if control remains with the individual. I’ve developed an app called ID Pocket that can store all non-payment items currently in your physical wallet. All the data is on your device and there is no tracking or ads. You can then display an item for someone to verify at whatever level of confidence they require (viewing the image, scanning a barcode, etc.). As Self Sovereign Identity becomes more common, you can store and present cryptographically verifiable credentials for those items needing a higher level of assurance.

  • You Need More Than Food to Survive

    In the event of a long-term disaster, there are non-food essentials that can be vital to your survival and well-being. Make certain you have these 50 non-food stockpile essentials. Sign up for your FREE report and get prepared.

    We respect your privacy.
    Malcare WordPress Security