Cold or Flu? Here’s How to Tell (And Why You Need to Know)
By Daisy Luther
You know the feeling. Your throat is dry. You feel tired, and perhaps a little stuffy. Then, a little cough starts, followed by that unmistakable taste in the mouth that screams “respiratory infection!” How do you know when that stuffy nose and scratchy cough is just a cold, and when it is something more serious, like influenza? Cold or flu? Here’s how to tell the difference.
Cold or Flu? What’s the big deal?
With the more virulent H3N2 influenza strain being widespread in almost every state in the US, it is so important to be able to tell the difference between the common cold and the flu. The H3N2 strain is a subtype of Influenza A that is particularly hard on less robust populations. This would include young children, the elderly, pregnant women, and anyone with a compromised immune system, such as diabetics and cancer patients.
This year, H3N2 is proving deadly to healthy adults in addition to the more at-risk groups just mentioned. In my neck of the woods, this 51-year old mother of two died from complications to influenza. This sadness shocked her family, as she was generally healthy, and they all thought it was just a cold. A 21-year old fitness buff and a healthy 20-year old mom have also died from the flu.
While the flu can pose a potentially life-threatening risk to anyone, these are not your usual influenza death demographics. The fact that this is the 100-year anniversary of the “Spanish Flu” of 1918, which targeted healthy adults, is not lost on me either. The anniversary itself is not an indicator of a pandemic. But, it is a sobering reminder of how easily influenza can mutate.
To complicate matters, this year’s flu vaccine has proven less than effective at preventing infection. It is estimated that this year’s flu vaccine is only 10% effective at preventing the flu. Influenza A strains are generally more serious than Influenza B or C strains and mutate more frequently. A higher rate of mutation means a greater chance our immune systems will be unprepared to fight it.
Cold or Flu? Here’s How to Tell
The tragedy is that most people who end up hospitalized or worse think they just have a bad cold. Both ailments start off with the same lousy, uncomfortable symptoms, so it can be hard to tell one from the other. They don’t realize the seriousness of their situation until it is too late.
When Is It a Cold?
The “common cold” is a group of over 200 different viruses that cause symptoms we call a “cold”. Approximately 40% of these are different strains of rhinovirus. Coronaviruses cause 20%. Respiratory Syncytial Virus (RVS) and Human Parainfluenza (HPIV) cause another 10%. Finally, the remaining 30% are caused by unknown viruses.
A cold is typically less severe than the flu. A cold has less intense symptoms and has a shorter duration. Some of these symptoms include:
- A stuffy or runny nose (One or the other, generally not both)
- Sore throat (mild to moderate)
- Body aches
- Fatigue (mild to moderate)
- Fever somewhat common in children, generally absent in adults.
- Duration – three to four days, and up to a week in those with weak or compromised immune systems
When Is It the Flu?
Three types of influenza virus cause the flu: Influenza A, B, and C. Influenza C is typically not a severe illness, and may look like a moderate to bad cold. Influenza A and B, however, do cause serious illness in humans.
The flu is more serious than a cold due to the secondary, bacterial infections possible after the flu. Bronchitis and pneumonia are the most common of these secondary infections.
Common flu symptoms include:
- A stuffy and running nose at the same time.
- Sore throat (moderate to severe)
- Deep hacking cough, frequent, dry, and non-productive
- Severe body aches
- Severe fatigue
- Fever with chills common to both children and adults
- Duration – up to two weeks
Does Color Matter?
This is a little gross, but we need to talk a little bit about phlegm. Doctors always ask if the phlegm you cough up, assuming your coughs are productive, have any color to them. I had always been told that if it was clear, it was just a cold. If it were yellow or green, it was a bacterial infection, and I was given antibiotics. Unfortunately, that isn’t accurate.
In truth, the color of your phlegm is an indicator of how hard your immune system is working. The color is produced by a large concentration of infection-fighting white blood cells called neutrophils. Neutrophils have an enzyme that lends the green color. The color can be more noticeable because the mucus has become thick, and more concentrated.
The yellowish, green is an indicator that your immune system is really working hard. It is not a way to distinguish between a viral or bacterial infection. However, if you are seeing thick, yellow or green mucus, it is a good indicator that you have a serious infection and should get checked out ASAP.
When Is It Neither a Cold or Flu?
There are a few situations where symptoms may be similar to a cold or flu but are something else entirely. A sinus infection has the same congestion as most colds. Sinus infections are caused by viruses, bacteria, fungi, nasal polyps, deviated septum, and allergic rhinitis.
Fungal lung infections are another possibility. While fungal respiratory infections are rare, if your illness has lasted over three weeks, it is time to consider if a fungal infection is to blame.
Bacterial infections, such as bronchitis and pneumonia mentioned above, are usually secondary illnesses. They can, in some cases, be the primary infection. A good example of this is tuberculosis. Tuberculosis is a bacterial infection that shares many symptoms of influenza.
Seasonal allergies (ex. hayfever) and indoor allergies (ex. pet dander) can look and feel like a cold.
Making Sense of It All
When you start to feel sick, start assessing yourself. Ask yourself:
- Are my symptoms severe?
- Do I have difficulty regulating my body temperature because of fever or chills?
- Is my phlegm yellow or green?
- Do I have a deep, hacking cough (as opposed to a cough from post nasal drip, or a dry “tickle”)
If you answered yes to any of these, you are more likely to have influenza than the common cold.
Only a laboratory test can tell you definitively if you have influenza or not. Even then, most doctors do not test for the flu unless you ask for it. It will be recorded as an “Influenza-like illness”, or ILI. By paying attention to your symptoms early, however, you can spot a potentially dangerous infection early.
Here are some home remedies that can help relieve the symptoms, regardless of which ailment you have.
About the Author
Cat Ellis is an herbalist, massage therapist, midwifery student, and urban homesteader from New England. She keeps bees, loves gardening and canning, and practice time at the range. She teaches herbal skills on her website, Herbal Prepper. Cat is a member of the American Herbalists Guild, and the author of two books, Prepper’s Natural Medicine and Prepping for a Pandemic.