By the author of The Flat Broke Cookbook and The Tower
Everyone everywhere is trying to save a buck lately. And with the increased cost of living it’s no wonder. Heck, a pound of ground beef could practically serve as a dowry for a young Victorian-era lady. But not all ideas are worthwhile, and some are downright dangerous.
In a few interesting threads (here and here) on Reddit, contributors shared the advice that they thought was the very worst in Frugal Land. Some of them could work in certain circumstances, but most, you may find, are not really worthwhile.
And there’s more. Some of this advice was great a generation or so ago. But times have changed dramatically, and we can no longer expect the same kind of economic stability that our parents had. We have had a period of massive inflation since 2020, and wages, in most cases, have not gone up to keep standards of living the same.
Are you out of the loop?
Sometimes my daughters inform me I’m out of the loop with regard to “how things are now.” And they’re right. When I left college to take an amazing job opportunity, my rent in a large city was around $300 a month. It was in that sweet spot of one quarter of my income, and I was very financially comfortable.
Now, however, the average renter in America is paying closer to 30-40% of their income, and one in five Americans are paying a whopping 50% or more of their monthly income to keep a roof over their heads.
CBS News reported the following statistics and numbers:
Subscribe to our newsletter
Trying to figure out how to stock up while prices keep climbing? We can help with our free guide and newsletter!
Meanwhile, the high cost of keeping a roof over your head is weighing on Americans across the country, with the median annual rent now at $21,480, Zillow’s data shows. The real estate firm estimates that nearly half of all U.S. renters are “cost-burdened,” meaning that more than 30% of their income goes toward housing expenses. Among families with children under 18, 54% are rent-burdened, Zillow found. ( source)
You may have bought your home years ago, when prices were more reasonable, and gotten it paid off by now. You may have made a series of wise decisions that have left you in a much better place financially.
But, it’s important to bear these numbers in mind when advising others. For some of us, life just happened in a way that unraveled our efforts toward stability, such as divorce, death of a spouse, or job loss. For others, especially the 20-somethings of today, they’re looking at an entirely different Monopoly board.
Onward to the worst advice…
“If you can afford rent, you can afford a mortgage.”
While that might have been true once, with the ever-increasing mortgage rates it might not be true any longer. What’s more, unless you have a hefty emergency fund, the cost of home repairs and appliances can require a huge chunk of money that you may have to pay using debt.
And that’s not all. Property taxes are massive in many desirable areas, and a decade of absolutely horrible natural disasters has dramatically increased the cost of homeowners insurance.
This isn’t always the case – if you can afford to buy your home outright, you may be better served by purchasing. If the mortgage payment is truly a drop in the financial bucket for you, and you have a very healthy emergency fund, then by all means, buy that house.
But if it’s a tight squeeze, you may be better off renting for a while longer.
“Buy a hybrid/electric car.”
In theory, a hybrid or electric vehicle would eventually save you money. But to get from now (the point of purchase) to then (the point of savings), there’s a whole lot of money in between.
Hybrid and electric vehicles tend to cost more significantly money to buy than gasoline-powered autos, for starters. Routine maintenance on a hybrid is about the same as a gas-powered car, with some claiming savings on brake wear-and-tear. Routine maintenance on an electric car is even less, due to fewer moving parts.
Buying your hybrid or electric car used can save you some money on the front end. But, it does bring you closer to a very big expense.
But don’t even get me started on the high cost of one repair that comes after the warranty days have passed: the battery. A battery replacement on a hybrid vehicle can cost anywhere from 2000 to 8000 dollars. Despite the fact you only need to replace it every 100,000-150,000 miles, you could pay for a new-to-you used car at the high end.
And an electric car? Sit down, Sally. If that unfortunate repair is needed outside of warranty, a replacement can cost you $6,500 to $20,000.
I bought the whole entire car I’ve driven for the past three years for $4k. I’m happy with my decision.
“Brush your teeth with X.”
There are all sorts of tips out there for ways to save money on toothpaste. Some folks suggest using just baking soda, others use coconut oil, and still others only use water.
I suppose it’s cheaper but only until you get the bill from the dentist. If you watch for sales, you can find a decent quality toothpaste at a very reasonable price. I always stock up when they’re on sale. Read this article on the importance of preventative dental care.
Obviously if it’s the end of the world, you gotta do what you gotta do, but that’s what prepping is for. My daughters tease me that my toothpaste stash might actually outlast the apocalypse.
Until then, get yourself some normal toothpaste and brush your teeth like your mama taught you, please.
“Move somewhere cheaper and commute.”
I often see advice about moving someplace cheaper, and that can be a wonderful solution in certain situations. But…not in all situations. It has worked well for me in the past, especially once I began working online.
But let’s think this through.
Are you leaving a great job to move someplace without the same work opportunities? You might want to rethink that with the job market as it is.
Are you planning to commute for work and school and just live an hour outside of town? Um… prepare to spend a fortune on gas PLUS loads of time as the commute gets longer when more people have the same idea. When you spend more time on the road, you have less time for cooking, meal-planning, yard work, and other types of activities that save you money.
Are you losing the support of nearby family and friends? It depends on your situation how much that will cost you. If you rely on a family member for childcare, get ready to have a heart attack when you see how much paying for fulltime childcare costs now. If you have health issues, having family around can be even more important. Not only might you need a ride to the hospital that doesn’t cost $20k out of pocket, but you might need someone to stop by and take care of your pets/children, etc.
This is advice that definitely can work, but not for everyone.
“Deny yourself life-quality/hygiene to save a buck.”
We know that on occasion, broke happens and you simply cannot afford to go to an event that costs money, whether for gifts or transportation or admission. And sometimes we can’t afford to maintain things like hair color or professionally manicured nails or a stylish wardrobe, which is more important in some jobs than others.
But that doesn’t mean you have to step back from life completely. Have you ever met someone who avoids weddings, birthdays, showers, and holiday events just because they want to save some money? I sincerely believe that’s no way to live. Sure, you don’t have to accept every single invitation that comes your way but for people you truly care about, I think that it’s worth the expenditure. You can find all sorts of creative ideas for gift-giving online, as well as thrifty menus and other treats.
Life is way to short to go full-on hermit in the name of saving money.
As far as your appearance goes, it’s one thing to skip the expensive trips to the salon or eschew buying new clothes, but it’s entirely another to avoid cleanliness and personal hygiene. Unless your situation is truly dismal and you no longer have running water or a home, you can almost always afford to stay clean, if not fashionable.
Please understand that we’re not talking about extreme scenarios or the end of the world here – we’re talking about the lengths that some folks go to in order to save money. And these are people who could afford to spend a little and embrace life (and smell good while doing it.)
Anything health and safety related
There are some places you just shouldn’t cut corners. Don’t drive a car with bad brakes for “as long as possible.” Don’t get cruddy windshield wipers. Don’t go to work when you’re too sick to be there (and when you’re likely to spread your illness.) Don’t skimp on checking out that questionable lump or spot. Don’t resist getting emergency treatment for something that could become severe or even life-threatening.
With things like these, it’s just not worth the risk to save some money. Either you’ll spend it now, or you’ll spend more later. Or, even worse, something terrible will happen due to your neglect.
Your safety and well-being are worth the extra money. If you can’t afford to fix your vehicle when it’s unsafe to drive, then take public transit or join a carpool. If you need urgent medical care, go to the hospital and set up a payment plan afterward.
Please don’t put yourself at risk to save money. Your life is worth more than that.
What do you think are the worst frugal living hacks out there?
Is there a piece of money-saving advice that makes your ears bleed every time you hear it? Is there a frugal living trick that you think is dead wrong? What is it, and why do you think it’s a bad idea?
Let’s talk about the worst frugal-living hacks in the comments section.









13 Responses
Not contributing to an employer’s 401K if available.
Mass-manufactured toothpastes have been around for but a tiny segment of humanity’s existence. The world still has isolated communities where despite (or perhaps owing to) a “primitive” lifestyle, people generally enjoy long, healthy, active lives.
That’s not to say that one’s teeth shouldn’t be cared for, just that means of doing so shouldn’t be rejected solely because they came into practice centuries or millennia ago or are “low-tech.” For example, I’ve long been using an herbal dental formula and have been more than satisfied with the results.
A lack of interest in vetting these hacks is a terrible excuse to ignore them as many DO WORK, but you’ll have to think for yourself to DISCERN which ones are for your and which are not. There are precious few things where the “good ol’ _________” is really good. We are far more primitive, and asinine in our general behaviors than pop-culture or the average person will ever know.
There are few broad subject “experts” out there as science is moving too fast to keep up these days. SO… dust off your old thinking cap and do your own research. How many people TODAY are doing this very thing after Covid? Trust no one, but yourself, and that means you may need to *GASP*…. LEARN SOMETHING new about your world so the electorate can become INFORMED.
I’m so tired of our culture’s veneration of intellectual laziness and lack of curiosity. The future belongs to those with BROAD KNOWLEDGE AND SKILLS, not a bunch of NPC puppets with unbridled corporatism and the latest TikTok challenge pulling their strings.
Ruining your health by living on instant ramen, instant mac and cheese, gas station snacks, soft drinks, and donuts.
Time is your precious resource and you can’t make any more of it. A longer commute may not be frugal, even when gas/diesel is not at government inflicted prices.
terrible article!!! These ideas would not help anyone. This is high school level advice!
Thanks, Bob, for your critique.
I believe there may be a mistake in communication between what I wrote and what you read.
I said these were the WORST frugal living hacks. And then I explained why each was not especially applicable.
Wishing you the very best.
Daisy
I had a root canal 36 years ago. I have not had any dental problems since then. Zero. I took the dentist’s advice and stopped using toothpaste. I switched to baking soda. Twice a day after flossing. $8 for toothpaste every two months is $48/year. I buy 4 pounds of baking soda for $3.50 at Walmart and it lasts for 2 years.
I’ve owned my property since 1982. Was able to move on it in 1989.
Here if you can’t find a job in the tiny area towns you’ll commute about 100 miles each way to work in the city and you’d better be in the city around 7 or earlier or you’re likely to be stuck in a slow crawl to get anywhere at rush hour.
I was widowed at 55 and at 57 I tried working in the city after I was widowed. It was too much making that drive, then driving kids to appointments, picking up infants from daycare to go to their foster homes etc. I was working for the state and it about killed me. I ended up paying a lady social worker $250 to sleep in a corner of her living room during the week and driving home just for weekends. I then found a job as manager for 2, 4 plexes for an out of state owner. It gave me a deep discount on a 2 bedroom apartment plus the chance to be paid for cleaning, renting, and doing small repairs and getting paid in cash each month. By then I’d changed employers and was working 5, 12 hour overnight shifts each week and only now and then going home. I remarried at age 61 and moved 30 minutes drive from the city. Retired at 65. 6 years later I moved back to my property, bought a 3 yearold repo mobile home, camped in an old mobilehome while fixing the repo. Glad to be back in my peaceful rural spot. At 74 I was widowed again and greatful to owe nothing to anyone. I’d put in solar power to my home about a year after moving back. Heating pellets, propane for hot water and cooking, some groceries ( by then I had chickens and rabbits and my big garden was back in production.) So not much in expenses.
I did a lot of my repairs until friends lost their home and business. I offered some storage space and an old mobile home if they made it live able. After that he did most of the repairs and kept all of our old vehicles going. I bought materials and added a few more tools to my collection.
I’d hate to be paying rents or mortgages today. My friend where I live in his apartment that is attached to his home rents an old mobile home in great condition for $1300 a month. It’s considered a bargain. I pay no rent. I’m his paid home health aide. He pays all the bills on the home and apartment. Actually that’s for his safety but I’m paid for 8 hours a day, seven days a week. If his health deteriorates there will be more hours but I can’t pick them up. So there will be more help with light housekeeping and possibly meal prep. It’s a fantastic way to build up some savings at my age.
It’s amazing what can be found if you look. My friend still lives on my property. She’s widowed now but she pays the on grid power bills and by being there, less walks away. No rent for her is really to my benefit. I pay the taxes. And if this job ends, home is still there waiting.
It’s my security blanket. I’d hate to be younger and having to cover all living expenses without owning a home. But a mortgage would be a burden as well.
When I lived in the city it was hard then. It would be harder now.
I’m still frugal. But my fixed income just met basic needs before the solar power for the home. I read books and did the work. I still approach things the same way. And I keep learning new ideas and new ways to use or improve old skills. My garden here is smaller but still produces a lot. I can, dehydrate, freeze and preserve much of my food. I had chickens until a few weeks ago when something killed them but I have freeze dried egg powder to last a long time. As I said. I’m frugal. I mend or remake my clothing. I take no medications. I use herbs and teas as my medication. I grow most of it now. I have hydroponic planters for my fresh greens all winter. 4 planters are full of 4” Fall greens that will move to my apartment kitchen for the winter under grow lights.
You mentions the expense of appliances- friend just had to buy a freezer a few weeks ago. The old one was full. A trip to the city and $1100 to save the food in a hurry. Today he was pricing a new dishwasher. $400- to over a $1300 depending on where, brand, and color. Would you believe colors and stainless steel are cheaper than white?! So not cheap.
He’d repaired the old freezer. The new one stopped working today so we transferred all that food but were able to save it. Monday we can get hold of the manufacturer of that new freezer and get it repaired or replaced. Yup. Owning can be expensive and frustrating.
Dental is mostly taken care of with a full upper denture. Good shape lower set of teeth. And I follow my old dentists favorite. Baking soda to brush with. Also grow flowers that stop a toothache and keep clove oil on hand. That helps with any dental pain. I found a rechargeable “ waterpick”. That can be big for travel and home. I bought two really cheap in a special so there is an extra. I have enough solar here for smaller things so I have found many rechargables to use.
Wow, your contributions just at this website might form the kernel of a book to be called, “The Best of Clergylady.”
Having been a “black sheep” most of my life, and not being educated (according to the world), I have found that pretty much all institution are not to be trusted, especially in matters of health, faith, and food.
A lot of what I have learned that works is ‘old ways’. I read very old book on the above topics going back to 1600’s.
I am 62, have no health issues, take no medication, don’t use doctors, dentist, or go to Incorporated churches. I am much more healthy, then people 1/2 my age.
Do your own research, and if it goes against God’s words, toss it. That is my approach.
Hi, Mitchell. Perhaps you might find interesting the work of physicist James McCanney, who’s widely considered a black sheep by mainstream astronomy and meteorology (but whose concepts in these domains seem absolutely correct).
Even though I fully supports and live by a frugal lifestyle, but the only thing I step way from cutting back are the paper towels. I could not find cloth towels to be a right alternative for it. They are not hygienic at all and one could not just wash them all the times.